I have decided to stick with love. Hate is too great a burden to bear. -- Martin Luther King, Jr.
Pull up a chair. Let's talk.
Mr. King, I’m Done With You
February 15, 2013Posted by on
Yes, I’m reading 11/22/63, purchased in paperback with my hard-earned cash. Based on the reviews, I thought this book was different. That maybe, just maybe, you had finally broken out of the endless repetitiveness that has been your schtick lately. I swore after reading Under the Dome that I was done with you. Talk about a story that is identical to so many others of you. Yes, change the premise a bit, the setting a little, and you have a new book. But the reality is the characters are the same, the good versus evil is the same, the story is basically what you have written over and over and over.
But those reviews of 11/22/63 suggested something new. Something better.
Well, apparently not. You’ve taken us right back to Derry which, along with Castle Rock, represents everything that is evil in the world. Just how many stories is it that you have written that bring us back to Derry? Well, thanks to Google, which took me to Goodreads, I can answer that question:
– The Running Man (1982)
– Pet Sematary (1983)
– “Uncle Otto’s Truck” (1983)
– “Mrs. Todd’s Shortcut” (1984)
– It (1986)
– The Tommyknockers (1987)
– “The Night Flier” (1988)
– Secret Window, Secret Garden (1990)
– Needful Things (1991)
– Insomnia (1994)
– “Autopsy Room Four” (1997)
– Bag of Bones (1998)
– “The Road Virus Heads North” (1999)
– Dreamcatcher (2001)
– The Dark Tower VII: The Dark Tower (2004)
– Lisey’s Story (2006)
– “Mute” (2007)
– “Fair Extension” (2010)
– 11/22/63 (2011)
Do you see a problem here, Mr. King? No, probably not. How can it be a problem if you’re continuing to rake in millions of dollars? How can it be a problem when you continue to top the bestseller list and have at least some critics singing your praises?
I read The Shining when I was in high school. Alone at home one Saturday evening. It was my first book of yours and I was terrified. Pet Sematary was equally frightening. I loved The Stand the Dead Zone. It was a classic. I looked forward to each chapter of the Dark Tower series until you ruined it with your incredibly self-absorbed, self-centered ending that was really nothing more than taking the easy way out.
I think that’s where my love of your storytelling began to erode. You completely f$%$#@’d up a great story with the ending to Dark Tower. The first book in the series — an absolute classic. The ending destroyed it all.
And, now, when it comes to your novels, you can do nothing more than write stories that are twice as long as they need to be and are really nothing more than repeats of prior stories or mining the deep, dark corners of places you’ve already been.
I would so love to see you take us somewhere new. Sadly, I don’t think you’re capable of it anymore.
P.S. Thanks to a friend I read the novel Replay a few months ago. Some of the similarities between that story and 11/22/63 are remarkable. You sure you can claim 11/22/63 as your own?
P.P.S. Please, please do not let me read another novel of yours.