KingMidget's Ramblings

Pull up a chair. Let's talk.

Giving Equal Time


Regular readers know I can at times find it difficult to hold back from pointing out the stupidity and hypocrisy of the right wing in this country.  As I grow older, I find some proposals put forth by the left wing equally worthy of scorn.  So … EQUAL TIME.

Out of nowhere this year, every Democrat seems to be talking about offering a free public university education to all who want it.  While I can see some value to that, I fundamentally believe in the idea that some things require buy in by those who participate.  And a college education is one of those things.  I’m really not sure why it should be free.  In California, four years of tuition and books at a state college comes to about $30,000.  Four years at a state university is somewhere in the neighborhood of $45,000 – 50,000.  In exchange for paying those costs, a college graduate earns on average $17,000 more per year coming out of college than a high school graduate does coming out of high school.  And that disparity only continues to grow over a lifetime of employment.  So, for a relatively small investment spread out over four years, a college graduate can earn hundreds of thousands, if not millions, more than somebody who doesn’t go to college.  Shouldn’t that graduate buy in and own a piece of that benefit?  And guess what, I really don’t care that some countries in Europe provide this benefit to their citizens.

But that’s not what this post is about.  I really wanted to talk about this.  Apparently, we are supposed to be concerned about equal gender accessibility and the way to open this discussion is legislation that proposes to make tampons untaxed in California.  Because, you know, women are the only ones who need tampons and some women can’t afford them and it can be very difficult to go to work or school or to the store when the monthly visitor is there and you can’t afford to keep it under control.  And because of that we should make tampons tax free.  No, actually, we should cover them with insurance or just make them free to everybody.  Or something like that.  Because this is a problem that denies women equal access.

Here’s the deal, I get it on some level.  I’m extremely grateful that I don’t have to deal with menstruation every month and the difficulties that accompany it.  In the too much personal information category, my wife is currently going through “the change” that older women go through and it has been extremely difficult for her and it has gone on now for several years.  So, I get it.  I also get that some women may not be able to afford tampons or may have to pick between putting food on the table and taking care of their personal hygiene needs.  I totally get that and the richest country in the world should have a way to prevent that.  But not taxing tampons, or making them free, for all purchasers is like using a nuclear bomb to kill a flea.

What’s particularly galling about the linked op-ed are the nonsensical arguments made to support this.  For instance,

What about our flex-pay standards? Currently, under Internal Revenue Service rules, you can use pre-tax dollars to receive reimbursement for condoms and pregnancy tests but not tampons. Which gender do you think drafted those rules?

So, basically, the IRS has determined you can use your pre-tax health savings account to cover the costs of condoms and pregnancy tests, but not tampons.  And the big hint at the end is that the author thinks this is clearly the result of our male-dominated world.  Let me see if I’ve got this correct.  Condoms are something only men care about?  Really?  I thought condoms were kind of a non-gender specific thing because they protect BOTH SEXES from unwanted sexually transmitted diseases and protect BOTH SEXES from unwanted pregnancy.  And pregnancy tests?  That’s a male issue also, put in to protect male interests?  Seriously?  I’m just kind of gobsmacked by this paragraph and its complete lack of any reality-based thinking and conclusions.

But there’s more.  At its root is the demand that women be treated differently because they are women and I will continue to fight this idea.  Tampons are a necessity of life for women during several decades of their lives.  If we need to start a conversation about what that means, then let’s talk about why we all have to pay for electricity, gas, internet service, and so many other necessities that we all must pay for.  Hell, shouldn’t food be free?

As I pondered this post and tried to come up with an analogy, I went for my morning run — a place where I always seem to figure things out.  I’m lactose intolerant and have a relatively mild form of irritable bowel syndrome.  The result of this is that I can spend a whole hell of a lot of time in bathrooms and it can deny me access to the benefits our great country provides us.  If I eat the wrong combination of things for lunch during the workday and there are meetings after lunch, I could be in serious trouble between trying to attend the meeting fully focused and dealing with what may very well be an explosive need.  If you know what I mean.

Years ago when I was first diagnosed with IBS, our family went on what became my favorite family vacation.  We went to Oregon and among other stops, stayed at Gold Beach for a couple of days.  In planning the trip, we discussed a mail boat tour — several hours on a small boat that runs up a river the way mail boats used to back in the good old days.  With no bathrooms available.  Because of what was going on in my digestive system at the time there was no way I was going on a boat for that length of time without a bathroom.  So, I hung back while my wife and older son went on the trip.

This is a problem that impacts me every single day of my life, not just three or five or seven days every month.  It impacts my decisions about going for runs, bicycle rides, long car trips, scheduling meetings, anything that involves potential conflicts with the unknowable and unexpected.  If you know what I mean

In an attempt to keep things under control, I take lactaid pills whenever I eat dairy and I have a Citrucel cocktail every morning.  I guarantee I spend more money on lactaid pills and Citrucel each month than women spend on tampons.  But these things don’t always work — in fact, the reality is that my digestive issues continue to impact me on a daily basis and will for the rest of my life.  I won’t go through “the change” and be removed of this curse.  And it would never, ever occur to me that I should get those items tax-free or completely free or even covered by insurance.  They are just a fact of my life, a part of who I am, an expense of living the life I live.  And we all, as human beings, have things like that in our lives that become a part of what is our existence — somethings are based on our gender or our race or some other immutable characteristic and others are based on other factors.  Why must there be special treatment for any of these things?

I would love to see our wealthy nation find a better way to provide necessities to those who cannot afford them, but I think that conversation needs to be cast in terms of all people and all necessities with a comprehensive solution that DOESN’T FOCUS ON OUR DIFFERENCES AND DEMAND SPECIAL TREATMENT BASED ON THOSE DIFFERENCES.  Particularly when the arguments made in support of special treatment are so blatantly idiotic and stupid and disrespectful of other people and their own needs.

 

 

Advertisements

9 responses to “Giving Equal Time

  1. cinthiaritchie January 17, 2016 at 9:21 pm

    Oh, honey, I think you’re trying to get me going, lol. I believe tampons and all of women’s “monthly” items should be tax exempt. They’re necessary, and having periods isn’t a disorder or disease that one needs to take medicine for but rather a natural cycle of life.
    What I don’t agree on, however, is how this topic is being used by too many people to push their own agendas–it really has little to do with whether a woman can afford tampons and more to do with propelling this person’s or this organization’s mindset forward.
    And of course it feeds other questions: Should adult diapers be exempt (are they??)? Infant diapers? Infant teething rings/toys? And, more importantly, who gets to decide what is and what isn’t taxable?
    But, I mean, that politicians are talking about this–that’s funny. The whole political scene has become a comedy. And the fact that so many people, especially people in the media, are trying to present it as serious–that’s even funnier. It’s hilarious.
    Thanks again for keeping me thinking. Have a great week.

    • kingmidget January 18, 2016 at 7:30 am

      I actually was thinking of you while I wrote this … wondering what your reaction might be if you read this. 😉

      But, I still don’t get the difference between the “necessity” of products needed to deal with periods and the “necessity” of products to treat other issues. Particularly as the issue is framed by the author of the op-ed — it’s about equal access. Women can’t gain access if they’re stuck at home because they can’t buy tampons. Well, if I’m having major stomach issues, that’s basically what happens to me.

      And I agree that it is somewhat funny that politicians are talking about this … imagine the squirming that will go on in the committee hearings as they discuss the topic. On the other hand, it’s not funny — seems there are more serious topics that should be discussed and that there should have been a better way to bring up the topic of accessibility.

  2. Carrie Rubin January 18, 2016 at 11:23 am

    I don’t see how it’s feasible to have free college in this country. We’re simply too large and already have too much debt. Nice thought though, especially for those of us with kids in college now. :/

    As for the second half of your post…um…I think I’ll just move on…

  3. JunkChuck January 18, 2016 at 3:58 pm

    I think that essential health items could go untaxed–In PA we don’t pay sales tax on unprepared food, clothing, shoes, and a few other things, but I see your point, too. From a purely selfish perspective, living with a wife and two teenage daughters, I’m all for free. Our monthly bill for feminine hygiene is spectacular, compared to the $12 a year I pay for a new four-pack of Hanes Boxers every Christmas. (I don’t just have four, but there’s a cycle, you know, and every winter the four worst pair go to the rag bin). I think we pay more for tampons and pads in three months that my entire annual beer budget (and beer is taxed). What’s fair about that?

    • kingmidget January 18, 2016 at 5:13 pm

      I’m willing to underwrite your feminine hygiene bill just to recognize the trauma you’re under. 😉 Just kidding. That was sexist and wrong! And I completely understand your underwear cycle. Now that you mention it, in some respects beer is an essential health item for me — I want it tax free!

  4. JunkChuck January 18, 2016 at 3:59 pm

    We could try the free college thing, say, for the next 4 years, just to see how it all works out….

  5. atkokosplace January 29, 2016 at 5:59 pm

    I am one year out of college expenses! Whew. My kids thank me for college on a regular basis. Yep, it hurt writing those checks. Free would have been awesome, but I really see your point in needing to pay for it…I just wish everyone had to pay. It isn’t right for people outside of the country to get to come here and have college paid for. So everyone should have to pay. Keep it fair. As for the other thing…well they could make their pads and wash them. Simple as that. No need to buy anything. Your posts always make me think…Oh and happy new year! 🙂

    • kingmidget January 29, 2016 at 6:07 pm

      I’m in the midst of two kids in college while I still owe on student loans for my jaunt through law school. So I totally get it. But giving everything away for free just doesn’t make sense to me.

      As for the other thing … If all I do with my blog is give people something to think about than maybe I have succeeded.

      Thank you for stopping by.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: