KingMidget's Ramblings

Pull up a chair. Let's talk.

Over 1,000 Pages Later I Don’t Know If I Can Go On


A couple of weeks ago, Queen Midget, youngest Prince Midget and I went to see the latest Hunger Games movie.  Count me as a fan of the first book and movie.  Huge fan.  Count me as a lesser fan of the second book and movie.  And as an even lesser fan of the third book.

The previews start — you know, what fills up about three hours and eighteen minutes of time before the movie actually starts.  They show a preview for a movie coming out in a few months.  It’s called Divergent.

A couple of months ago, my oldest son asked me to buy him a book.  It was called Divergent.  Wanting to encourage him to continue reading in this age of technology, I did.  He liked it and began talking about how it was the next “big thing.”  The movie preview suggests he may be right about that.  (Side note: yesterday, on Facebook, I saw that one of his friends got a Divergent-related tattoo.  See, it is the next “big thing.”)

The preview intrigued me.  I checked the book out on Amazon.  It’s part of a trilogy.  I bought the first book for my Kindle and was hooked.  It’s kind of like Hunger Games, kind of not, but it’s a good story, whether it’s written incredibly well or not.  So, I downloaded the second book in the series — Insurgent.  Read it as well.  The two books combined are over 1,000 pages.

And here’s where the trouble started.  For some reason, I decided to check out some of the reviews for the third book — Allegiant.  Maybe it was because the overall rating on Amazon for the third book was significantly lower than the overall rating for the first two.  When I decide to check out reviews, I typically look at the lower reviews first.  Why?  I don’t know.  Just seems that they might be the more instructive.

I started reading them and learned something about the third book.  While the first two books are told from the first person perspective of Beatrice/Tris — the primary female protagonist — the third book switches between Beatrice/Tris and Tobias/Four.  And, there was also unhappiness with the ending — yes, unfortunately, as a result of reading the reviews, I now know more about the ending than I’d like.

I downloaded the third book and started reading.  The first book was over 500 pages.  The second book was over 500 pages.  The third book is also over 500 pages.  I’m about 1/5 of the way through the book and I want to throw it against the wall.  Only problem is, it’s on my Kindle, so I can’t.  (Reason #1 e-readers are a problem.)

After over 1,000 pages of getting the story through Beatrice/Tris, I’m now being forced to flip back and forth between her and Tobias/Four.  With every single chapter where it’s told from his perspective, I find myself constantly having to remember that I’m reading Tobias’ version of the story rather than Beatrice’s.  And, that’s a problem.  I keep thinking it’s Beatrice doing the thinking and talking and feeling and then something is said and I have to snap back to realize it’s Tobias.

A couple of weeks ago, I met with Zoe.  One of the things we did was talk about Northville Five and Dime.  She said something that was very interesting.  It’s a concept that all writers should keep in mind.  As a writer, you owe it to your reader to not make it difficult.  Don’t make the reader work for it.  That’s not quite the way she said it, but it’s close enough.  A reader should not have to work in the process of reading your story.

Right now, reading Allegiant is far too much work.  As much as I’d like to read to the conclusion (even if I know too much because of those reviews), I’m getting tired of having to remind myself who the narrator is with each chapter.

This would be completely different if the author had started from book one with this idea of switching back and forth between the two main characters.  But she didn’t.  What the hell was she thinking and what was her editor and publisher thinking when they went forward with the third book as is?

 

Advertisements

10 responses to “Over 1,000 Pages Later I Don’t Know If I Can Go On

  1. Taryn January 4, 2014 at 9:21 pm

    Yes! I had to consciously remind myself it wasn’t Tris talking way too many times while reading the Tobias chapters. I wish the author hadn’t made that change in the third book.

  2. justmoo33 January 5, 2014 at 6:47 am

    That’s interesting. When I read The Boy Who Lit Up The Sky by J. Naomi, I loved the changes of POV (all characters except the hero). I wonder if it was the change of style between books which was a no-no? Mind you, I heartily agree about not making if difficult for your readers!

    • kingmidget January 5, 2014 at 7:16 am

      It was the change in style from the first two books to the third. I’m working on a story that will shift back and forth between three characters, but it’s obvious from the start. It’s not like I go along with one character for two thirds of the story and all of a sudden start switching back and forth. It’s a great way to tell a story, as long as you’re consistent. Starting it up with the third book in a series is just the opposite. I may have to check out The Boy Who Lit Up The Sky.

  3. sknicholls January 5, 2014 at 9:30 am

    The House of Crimson and Clover series is written like that, with multiple points of view, but Sarah Cradit distinctly marked each chapter with the name of the character whose POV she was using and it worked for me. It was a complex, layered story and I loved it. However, it doesn’t work for everybody. She had many reviews praising the method and just as many criticizing it. I am debating with the book I am writing now. I want to stay in one POV, that of one of two sisters, and yet, her perspective may not be the best way to tell the other sister’s perspective, so I am at an impasse.

  4. Theryn January 5, 2014 at 2:21 pm

    Hmm. I kinda think if you keep forgetting which character is narrating, the problem isn’t the switching back and forth but that the voices are too similar (not distinctive enough). You really should be able to tell which character’s head you’re in.

    Also: the first rule of reading reviews is don’t read them until after you’ve read the book 🙂

    • kingmidget January 5, 2014 at 2:48 pm

      This is what worries me about Northville Five & Dime. That the voices of my three characters are too similar. Zoe has assured me they aren’t, but still I worry. As for reading reviews … it’s like being drawn to a car crash, I just had to see why the third book was rated so much lower.

  5. lumar1298 January 6, 2014 at 9:55 am

    Thanks for the info. I’ve seen both 1 & 2, but would like to read the trilogy. At least now I have some insight…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: